Learn Health Data

Courses / How a Claim Gets Paid /

Module 2

The claim's journey

A claim is the bill a provider sends to a payer. Here is the whole trip once, start to finish. Later modules zoom in on each step.

How a claim moves: provider, clearinghouse, payer, remittance, patient billFive steps in order. The provider sends the claim to a clearinghouse, which forwards it to the payer. The payer decides and pays, sends a remittance back to the provider, and the provider bills the patient for the patient's share. The same steps are listed in words below the diagram.1. ProviderGives care, records codes and charges,and sends the claim (837P or 837I)2. ClearinghousePuts the claim in the standard formatand forwards it to the payer3. PayerFor Original Medicare, a contractor (MAC)sets the allowed amount and pays4. RemittancePayment explanation (835) back to theprovider, with each adjustment5. Patient billThe patient's share, such as thedeductible and coinsurance

The same chain in words:

  1. Provider: gives the care, records what was done as codes with a charge for each, and sends a claim. Clinicians use the professional claim (837P), and facilities use the institutional claim (837I).
  2. Clearinghouse: a middleman that turns a claim into the standard electronic format and forwards it to the payer. Not every claim goes through one.
  3. Payer: the health plan decides what it will pay. For Original Medicare, a Medicare Administrative Contractor (MAC) processes the claim and sets the allowed amount.
  4. Remittance: the payer sends the provider a payment explanation, the electronic remittance advice (835), that lists the payment and each adjustment.
  5. Patient bill: the provider bills the patient for the patient's share, such as the deductible and coinsurance.

Step by step

1. The visit, the codes and the charge

The provider gives the care and records what was done as procedure codes. Outside the hospital inpatient setting these are HCPCS codes: Level I is CPT®, maintained by the American Medical Association, and Level II is maintained by CMS. (CMS) Each service line also gets a two-digit place of service code that says where the service happened (CMS), and the provider's billed charge for that line (NUCC). See the HCPCS and place of service concept pages.

In Original Medicare, the law requires the provider to file the claim for covered services; the patient doesn't. (Medicare.gov)

2. The claim

Clinicians bill on a professional claim: the electronic 837P, or the paper CMS-1500. Facilities bill on an institutional claim: the electronic 837I, or the paper CMS-1450 (UB-04). (CMS, CMS) Medicare requires claims to be sent electronically as a condition for payment, under the Administrative Simplification Compliance Act (ASCA). (CMS) See the claims concept page.

3. The clearinghouse

Some providers send claims straight to the payer. Others use a clearinghouse or billing service that sends them on the provider's behalf. (CMS) A clearinghouse can translate a claim from a nonstandard format into the standard transaction and forward it to the payer. (CMS)

4. The payer decides

For Original Medicare, a Medicare Administrative Contractor processes the claim. (CMS) The decision sets the allowed amount: the total Medicare approves for the service. That total is split between what Medicare pays, the deductible and coinsurance the patient owes, and anything a third party owes. (CMS)

5. The remittance

After Medicare processes a claim, it sends the provider a remittance: an electronic remittance advice (ERA) in the X12 835 format, or a standard paper remit. One remittance usually covers many claims, and it lists the reason and the amount of every adjustment. One check or electronic funds transfer (EFT) pays for all the claims in that remittance. (CMS) Reading the adjustment codes gets its own module later.

6. The patient's bill

The patient gets a Medicare Summary Notice that shows how much they're responsible for. (CMS) For most Part B services, after the yearly deductible the patient usually pays 20% of the Medicare-approved amount. (Medicare.gov) A provider who accepts assignment usually waits for Medicare to pay its share before asking the patient to pay theirs. (Medicare.gov) Some services have no patient share at all: a flu shot costs the patient nothing if the provider accepts assignment. (Medicare.gov)

Billed vs allowed vs paid

Three money amounts follow a claim through the chain, and mixing them up is a common mistake in billing data.

AmountWhat it meansIn this site's tables
Billed (submitted charge)The provider's own charge, set before the payer decides anything.providers_hi.total_submitted_charges (provider totals only)
AllowedWhat Medicare approves: Medicare's payment plus the patient's deductible and coinsurance plus any third-party amount.providers_hi.total_medicare_allowed, provider_services_hi.avg_medicare_allowed
PaidWhat Medicare paid after the deductible and coinsurance were taken out.providers_hi.total_medicare_payment, provider_services_hi.avg_medicare_payment

Definitions from the CMS data dictionary. (CMS)

Across all Hawaii providers in this site's data, billed charges add up to about $983.0 million, the allowed amount to $339.4 million, and Medicare's payment to $264.1 million.

Billed vs allowed vs paid for all Hawaii providers

DuckDB SQL

SELECT ROUND(SUM(total_submitted_charges)) AS billed, ROUND(SUM(total_medicare_allowed)) AS allowed, ROUND(SUM(total_medicare_payment)) AS paid FROM providers_hi;

Pitfalls

Practice

Two exercises on the Hawaii data: the money on one HCPCS Level II code, then where services happen and what Medicare paid in each setting. They use the same runner and progress as the exercises.

Sources